I recently wrote a detailed piece on the Hanbali perspective on Istighatha and Tawassul. In that piece, I interviewed Sh. Kareem Helmy, a Hanbali scholar and researcher based in Egypt, to provide details on what Hanbali scholars say about these two matters. We briefly discussed Ibn Taymiyyah in it as well but the main focus was other scholars of the Hanbali school because Ibn Taymiyyah’s position on these matters is well-known.
Dr. Yasir Qadhi’s recent lecture on the topic of Istighatha has resulted in much controversy and backlash. As a result of this lecture, I have come across quite a few people in the last few weeks who have become confused about what Ibn Taymiyyah’s views are on this topic. Therefore, I wanted to write a quick summary of his views on this subject using his own writings.
Ibn Taymiyyah in Mukhtasar al-Fatawaa al-Misriyyah divides those who go to graves into three categories and provides a ruling for each. Here is a screenshot:
The summary of his three categories are as follows (I’m not going to do word-for-word translation):
First category: Those who go to graves to ask the dead for things which are exclusive to Allah’s power alone, such as, seeking forgiveness, granting a child, providing guidance, curing illness, saving from Hell, granting paradise, etc. These examples are explicitly mentioned by him a few pages before the screenshot on pg. 191. This is when the caller believes that the dead entity itself acts to provide such things. He considers this shirk without question.
Second category: Those who go to graves to ask the dead to make supplications on their behalf because they believe that the dead entity’s supplication is more likely to be answered due to his righteousness. He considers this practice permitted while the person was alive but not after their dead. Therefore, he views this practice forbidden but does not call it shirk. In one of his other books called Qaa’idah Jaleelah Fee al-Tawassul al-Waseelah, he says about this type, “Nobody from the salaf did such a thing because it is a means to shirk and worshipping other than Allah.”
Third category: Those who go to graves and do not call out the dead, rather, they ask Allah but use the status of the dead entity as a tawassul. For example, they may supplicate, “Oh Allah! grant me such and such by the high rank or blessing of so and so!” He also considers this practice forbidden but does not use the word shirk. However, majority of the Hanbali scholars disagree with him on this and permit this type especially as it relates to the grave of the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) as was discussed in my previous article on the subject.
The above is a brief of summary of his views on this topic.